Table of Contents

What Is Instant Pot Stuffed Pepper Soup?

Think of it as unstuffed peppers. Instead of stuffing peppers one by one, you simmer the same classic elements together—ground meat, peppers, tomatoes, broth, and rice—into a hearty, spoonable soup. The Instant Pot shines here because:

It sautés and pressure-cooks in one pot (less cleanup).
It yields evenly tender peppers and a deeply melded broth in a fraction of stovetop time.
It’s forgiving with timing and batch size.

The texture is brothy-hearty, not stew-thick by default—perfect for ladling into big bowls and topping with a shower of fresh herbs, a pinch of spice, or a little grated cheese if that’s your vibe.

Why Use the Instant Pot (Beyond Speed)

One-pot workflow: Brown, deglaze, pressure cook, and serve from the same insert.
Flavor development: Sautéing aromatics and meat first builds fond; pressure amplifies those flavors into the broth.
Pepper perfection: Pressure gently softens peppers without turning them to mush (assuming you follow the timing below).
Predictability: Once you settle on a rice strategy (inside vs. separate), your pot will turn out consistent bowls every time.

Ingredient Spotlight

Protein (choose one or combine):

Ground beef (80/20–90/10): Classic stuffed-pepper flavor; a little fat equals richness.
Ground turkey or chicken: Lighter in flavor; takes seasoning beautifully.
Italian sausage: Adds fennel, garlic, and depth—great mixed half-and-half with beef or turkey.
Vegetarian swap: Brown plant-based crumbles or use cooked lentils; keep the same aromatics and broth.

Peppers & Aromatics:

Bell peppers: Use a mix of green (classic bite) and red/yellow/orange (sweetness and color).
Onion & garlic: Build the fragrance at the sauté stage.
Optional extras: diced celery or carrot for more body.

Tomato Base:

Diced tomatoes for chunk; crushed tomatoes or passata for a silkier body; tomato sauce for a middle ground.
A tablespoon or two of tomato paste intensifies umami and color.

Rice (see “Best Rice Strategy” for timing):

Long-grain white (jasmine or basmati): Fastest in-pot.
Brown rice: Chewy, nutty; needs longer pressure time or cooking separately.
Quinoa: Quick-cooking alternative; lovely texture.
Cauliflower rice: Stir in after pressure cooking for low-carb vibes.

Broth & Seasoning:

Beef or chicken broth, bay leaf, paprika, Italian seasoning, oregano, black pepper, crushed red pepper (optional heat).
Finish with a splash of red wine vinegar or lemon juice to brighten.

Finishing Touches (optional):

Fresh herbs: parsley or basil.
Grated Parmesan, diced mozzarella, or a dollop of sour cream.
For Tex-Mex flair: cumin, chili powder, roasted corn, and cilantro.

Bowl of Instant Pot stuffed pepper soup with peppers, rice, and parsley

The Best Rice Strategy (Pick Your Path)

There are two winning approaches:

Option A — Cook Rice in the Soup (one-pot convenience)

Pros: Easiest, starch lightly thickens broth, fewest dishes.
Watch-outs: Rice continues to hydrate after cooking; leftovers get thicker.

Guidelines (typical ranges):

White long-grain rice in pot: 10 minutes at High Pressure + 10 minutes natural release.
Quinoa in pot: 1 minute at High + 10 minutes natural release (or 0 minutes with a longer NPR).
Brown rice in pot: 20–22 minutes at High + 10 minutes natural release (but peppers will be very soft—consider separate rice if texture matters).

Option B — Cook Rice Separately (best leftovers)

Pros: Soup stays brothy; rice doesn’t blow out on day 2; easy to portion control.
Workflow: Pressure-cook soup without rice → fold in warm cooked rice per bowl at serving.

Equipment & Setup

6-qt or 8-qt Instant Pot (8-qt for doubling).
Long spatula or wooden spoon for deglazing.
Ladle, bowls, and storage containers if meal-prepping.
Consider turning Keep Warm OFF before natural release if you want the pressure to drop a little faster.

Step-by-Step: Instant Pot Stuffed Pepper Soup

Ingredients:

1–1.25 lb ground beef (or turkey/chicken, or a 50/50 beef-sausage mix)
1 large onion, diced
3 cloves garlic, minced
3 bell peppers (mix of green + red/yellow), diced
1 can (14–15 oz) diced tomatoes (fire-roasted if you like)
1 can (14–15 oz) crushed tomatoes or tomato sauce
1–2 Tbsp tomato paste (optional but recommended)
5 cups broth (beef or chicken)
¾ cup long-grain white rice (rinsed)
1–1½ tsp kosher salt (to taste), ½ tsp black pepper
1½ tsp Italian seasoning + 1 tsp paprika
1 bay leaf
Optional: pinch crushed red pepper; 1–2 tsp red wine vinegar to finish
Garnish: parsley, grated Parmesan, dollop of sour cream (optional)

Method:

Sauté & Brown (build flavor).
Set Sauté (High). Film the insert lightly with oil. Add onion and a pinch of salt; cook 2–3 minutes until translucent. Add garlic; stir 30 seconds. Crumble in meat; cook, stirring, until browned and no visible pink remains. Spoon off excess fat if desired.
Season & Deglaze.
Stir in Italian seasoning, paprika, black pepper, and tomato paste; toast 30–60 seconds. Pour in ½–1 cup broth; scrape up all fond until the bottom is spotless (prevents BURN).
Load the Pot (layer to avoid BURN).
Add diced peppers, remaining broth, rinsed rice, bay leaf, and salt. Add tomatoes last and don’t stir them to the bottom. This tomato-on-top layering helps protect the heating element from thick sauces.
Pressure Cook.
Lock lid; set High Pressure, 10 minutes. The pot will take a few minutes to come up to pressure.
Release.
Let pressure naturally release for 10 minutes, then quickly release the rest. Open the lid away from you.
Adjust & Brighten.
Stir, remove bay leaf, and check the spoon thickness. If too thick, splash in broth. If you want a touch more punch, add a teaspoon or two of red wine vinegar or lemon juice. Taste and adjust salt/pepper.
Serve.
Ladle into warm bowls. Garnish with parsley, a pinch of red pepper, and Parmesan or a dollop of sour cream if you like.

Notes for Other Grains:

Brown rice in soup: 20–22 minutes High + 10 minutes NPR (peppers get very soft).
Quinoa in soup: 1 minute High + 10 minutes NPR (or 0 minutes High + 12–15 minutes NPR).
Separate rice method: Cook rice on the side; fold into bowls just before serving.

Variations & Substitutions

Protein Profiles:

Half beef + half Italian sausage: Deeper, savory finish with fennel and garlic notes.
All turkey/chicken: Dial up paprika, oregano, and a touch more salt to compensate for leaner flavor.
Vegetarian: Brown plant-based crumbles or add 2 cups cooked lentils after pressure cooking.

Rice & Grain Swaps:

Brown rice: Chewier; plan for longer cook time or separate cooking.
Quinoa: Earthy, light; very short pressure time.
Cauliflower rice: Stir in after pressure cooking so it stays nubby, not mushy.

Flavor Routes:

Italian-forward: Extra basil/oregano; finish with Parmesan.
Smoky: Smoked paprika + fire-roasted tomatoes.
Tex-Mex: Cumin, chili powder, roasted corn, and cilantro at the end.
Spicy: Add chopped jalapeño with peppers or finish with Calabrian chile paste.

Make-Ahead, Storage, Freezing & Reheating

Fridge (3–4 days): Cool quickly, then store in airtight containers. The rice will continue to swell; thin with broth when reheating if needed.
Freezer (up to ~3 months): For best texture, freeze without rice, then add fresh-cooked rice when serving.
Reheat: Warm gently on the stovetop or using Sauté (Low) in the Instant Pot, adding broth to loosen if thick.

Troubleshooting

“BURN” Warning

Why it happens: Stuck fond, thick tomato on the bottom, or not enough liquid.
Fix it: Always deglaze after browning; layer tomatoes on top; verify your broth volume. If “BURN” triggers, cancel, quick release as needed, scrape the bottom clean, add ½–1 cup broth, and resume.

Mushy Rice

Why: Too long at pressure or too much lingering heat.
Fix: Drop to 8–9 minutes for white rice + 10 min NPR; or switch to the separate-rice method.

Too Thin / Too Thick

Too thin: Simmer on Sauté (Low/Normal) 3–8 minutes; stir in a spoon of tomato paste.
Too thick: Add warm broth ¼–½ cup at a time, stir, and taste for salt.

Bland

Salt-acid balance is everything; finish with vinegar or lemon. Consider a pinch of sugar if your tomatoes are extra tangy, and add fresh herbs.

Serving Ideas & Pairings

Toppings: Fresh parsley, basil chiffonade, grated Parmesan, mozzarella pearls, red pepper flakes.
Sides: Warm, crusty bread, garlic knots, or a simple green salad.
Texture play: Add a small scoop of rice to the bowl first, then ladle soup over for a layered experience.

Frequently Asked Questions

1) How long do I cook Instant Pot Stuffed Pepper Soup?
For white long-grain rice cooked in the soup: 10 minutes High + 10 minutes NPR is reliable. Quinoa needs ~1 minute High + 10 minutes NPR; brown rice is 20–22 minutes High + 10 minutes NPR (peppers get soft).

2) Should I use natural release or quick release for soup?
Do 10 minutes of natural release to calm starchy bubbles, then quick-release the rest. It keeps the valve from sputtering and protects texture.

3) Can I use brown rice?
Yes. Expect a longer pressure time (20–22 minutes High). If you want firmer peppers or best leftovers, cook brown rice separately and add it when serving.

4) What if I get a “BURN” notice?
Cancel → quick release as needed → open and scrape the bottom clean while adding ½–1 cup broth → re-seal and continue. Next time, layer tomatoes on top and don’t stir them in.

5) Can I freeze this soup?
Absolutely. For best texture, freeze without rice. Add freshly cooked rice when reheating so the grains don’t bloat.