Chocolate Peppermint Sandwich Cookies with creamy mint filling and crushed candy canes

Irresistible Chocolate Peppermint Sandwich Cookies (Festive Holiday Recipe)

by

Chocolate Peppermint Sandwich Cookies

If you’re dreaming of rich chocolate cookies hugged around a cool, creamy peppermint filling, you’re in exactly the right place. Chocolate Peppermint Sandwich Cookies are everything a festive treat should be: indulgent, pretty, and packed with that nostalgic holiday flavor that makes you want to bake “just one more batch.”

These pretty little sandwich cookies are perfect for cookie swaps, Christmas dessert tables, and gifting to family, friends, and neighbors. They look like they came straight from an artisan bakery, but they’re completely achievable in your own kitchen with a few smart tips and a reliable recipe.

What Are Chocolate Peppermint Sandwich Cookies?

Chocolate Peppermint Sandwich Cookies are classic sandwich cookies: two chocolate cookies pressed around a soft, sweet peppermint filling. Think of them as a cross between a brownie, a peppermint patty, and a fancy bakery cookie.

At their core, they’re usually:

  • A chocolate cookie that can be:
    • Soft and brownie-like
    • Chewy and slightly crisp around the edges
  • A peppermint buttercream or peppermint cream cheese filling
  • Optional decorations like crushed candy canes, chocolate drizzle, or sprinkles

Ingredient Breakdown: Building the Perfect Cookie & Filling

Key Ingredients for the Chocolate Cookie Shell

The base of Chocolate Peppermint Sandwich Cookies is a simple but carefully balanced chocolate cookie dough. Here’s what each ingredient does:

  • All-purpose flour
    • Provides structure
    • Too much = dry cookies
    • Too little = cookies spread too much
  • Cocoa powder
    • Gives the cookies their deep chocolate flavor and color
    • Natural cocoa vs Dutch-process cocoa will change flavor and sometimes texture
    • Use a good-quality cocoa for a richer, more luxurious taste
  • Butter
    • Adds flavor and tenderness
    • Room-temperature butter creams well with sugar and traps air, giving the cookies a softer texture
  • Sugar
    • Granulated sugar for structure and crisp edges
    • Brown sugar (if used) adds a hint of caramel flavor and chewiness
  • Eggs
    • Bind the ingredients
    • Add richness and help with structure
  • Vanilla extract
    • Rounds out the chocolate flavor
    • Keeps the cookie from tasting flat or one-note
  • Leavening (baking soda and/or baking powder)
    • Helps the cookies rise and stay light
  • Salt
    • Balances sweetness
    • Enhances chocolate and peppermint flavors

Peppermint Filling Ingredients

The star of the show inside:

  • Butter (and/or cream cheese)
    • Creates a rich, creamy base
    • Cream cheese adds tang and a cheesecake-style feel
  • Powdered sugar
    • Sweetens and thickens the filling
    • Gives that smooth, melt-in-your-mouth texture
  • Peppermint extract
    • Highly concentrated, so you only need a small amount
    • Add drop by drop and taste as you go
  • Vanilla extract
    • Softens the sharpness of peppermint
    • Adds depth and warmth
  • Milk or cream
    • Adjusts consistency
    • Makes the filling fluffier and easier to pipe
  • Optional food coloring
    • A few drops of red can make the filling blush pink
    • You can also swirl colors for a candy cane effect

Toppings & Mix-Ins

To make your cookies stand out even more:

  • Crushed candy canes
    • Roll the edges of the filled cookies in crushed pieces
    • Adds color, crunch, and extra peppermint sparkle
  • Sprinkles and sanding sugar
    • Add festive color and texture
  • Chocolate chips or chunks
    • Fold into the cookie dough for a double chocolate impact
  • Melted chocolate drizzle
    • Dark chocolate for intensity
    • White chocolate for a candy-cane look
Chocolate Peppermint Sandwich Cookies with creamy mint filling and crushed candy canes

Choosing the Best Chocolate & Peppermint Products

Because Chocolate Peppermint Sandwich Cookies rely so heavily on both chocolate and peppermint, ingredient quality matters.

Cocoa Powder Tips

  • Use a good-quality cocoa powder:
    • Dutch-process for deeper color and smoother flavor
    • Natural cocoa for a brighter, more straightforward chocolate taste
  • Follow the recipe you’re using:
    • Many recipes are developed specifically for one type of cocoa

Peppermint Extract vs Other Mint Flavors

  • Peppermint extract is cooler and more candy-cane-like
  • Mint extract can include spearmint, which tastes more like chewing gum
  • Peppermint oil is extremely strong; use sparingly if you ever swap it in

Always start with less extract than you think you need. You can add more, but you can’t take it out, and overly strong peppermint can overwhelm the chocolate.

Essential Tools & Equipment

You don’t need fancy restaurant equipment to make Chocolate Peppermint Sandwich Cookies, but a few tools make things easier:

  • Mixing bowls
  • Hand mixer or stand mixer
  • Measuring cups and spoons
  • Kitchen scale (optional but great for accuracy)
  • Cookie scoops for evenly sized cookies
  • Baking sheets
  • Parchment paper or silicone baking mats
  • Cooling racks
  • Offset spatula for spreading filling
  • Piping bags and tips (or a zip-top bag with the corner snipped off)

Step-by-Step: Making the Chocolate Cookie Dough

Creaming Butter and Sugar

Start by beating softened butter with sugar until it’s light and fluffy. This step:

  • Traps air in the mixture
  • Helps create a lighter, more tender cookie
  • Usually takes several minutes on medium speed

Don’t rush this step; well-creamed butter and sugar make a noticeable difference in texture.

Adding Eggs & Vanilla

Once your butter and sugar are creamed:

  • Add eggs one at a time, mixing just until incorporated
  • Add vanilla extract and mix until combined

Avoid overbeating at this stage—too much beating can make the dough tough later.

Sifting and Mixing Dry Ingredients

In a separate bowl:

  • Whisk or sift:
    • Flour
    • Cocoa powder
    • Leaveners (baking soda, baking powder, or both)
    • Salt

Sifting helps:

  • Break up any cocoa lumps
  • Evenly distribute ingredients
  • Prevent streaks of flour or cocoa in the dough

Combining Wet and Dry Ingredients

Add the dry ingredients to the wet mixture in two or three additions:

  • Mix on low speed just until no dry streaks remain
  • Scrape down the bowl as needed
  • Fold in any chocolate chips or mix-ins at the end

Stop as soon as everything is combined; overmixing can make the cookies denser.

Chilling, Shaping & Baking the Cookies

Why Chilling the Dough Matters

Chilling the cookie dough is crucial for Chocolate Peppermint Sandwich Cookies because:

  • It firms up the butter
  • Helps control spread in the oven
  • Intensifies the chocolate flavor

Chill the dough for at least 30 minutes, and longer if it’s very soft.

Shaping Options

You have several options for shaping:

  • Scooped drop cookies
    • Use a cookie scoop for consistency
    • Gently roll into balls if you want a smoother shape
  • Slice-and-bake
    • Shape the dough into logs, chill, then slice into rounds
    • Creates very uniform cookies
  • Cut-out circles
    • Roll the dough out and use a round cutter
    • Best for ultra-even sandwich cookies

Baking for Soft vs Crisp Cookies

Bake on parchment-lined sheets:

  • For softer cookies:
    • Bake until the edges are just set, and the centers still look slightly soft
  • For crisper cookies:
    • Bake another minute or two until the centers look fully set

Let the cookies cool on the baking sheet for a few minutes before transferring to a wire rack to cool completely.

Making the Peppermint Filling

Buttercream vs Cream-Cheese Style

For the filling, you can choose between:

  • Classic peppermint buttercream
    • Lighter, sweeter, and very stable
    • Ideal for stacking and gifting
  • Peppermint cream cheese filling
    • Slight tang, like peppermint cheesecake
    • A bit softer, but incredibly luxurious

Both start by beating butter (and cream cheese, if using) until smooth and fluffy.

Adding Peppermint Extract

Peppermint extract is powerful, so gently does it:

  • Start with a small amount (for example, 1/4 teaspoon)
  • Taste and add more drop by drop as needed
  • Balance with a bit of vanilla to keep the mint from tasting too sharp

Adjusting Consistency

To get the perfect texture:

  • If the filling is too stiff:
    • Add milk or cream a teaspoon at a time
  • If the filling is too runny:
    • Add more powdered sugar
    • Chill briefly to firm it up

Assembling, Decorating & Finishing Touches

Matching Cookie Pairs

Once your cookies are completely cool:

  • Sort them by size and thickness
  • Pair them up so each sandwich has matching halves

This makes your Chocolate Peppermint Sandwich Cookies look neat and professional.

Filling the Cookies

To assemble:

  1. Pipe or spread a generous dollop of peppermint filling onto the flat side of one cookie.
  2. Top with its partner cookie, flat side down.
  3. Gently press until the filling spreads to the edges without spilling over.

Using a piping bag gives you a very clean, consistent look, but a small offset spatula will also work.

Decorative Edges & Toppings

Now for the fun part:

  • Roll the sides of each filled cookie in:
    • Crushed candy canes
    • Mini chocolate chips
    • Festive sprinkles
  • Drizzle the tops with:
    • Melted dark chocolate
    • Melted white chocolate
  • Add a tiny sprinkle of crushed candies on top while the drizzle is still wet

Let the cookies sit until the filling and any chocolate drizzle have set before stacking or packaging.

Chocolate Peppermint Sandwich Cookies with creamy mint filling and crushed candy canes

Flavor Variations & Creative Twists

You can use the same base dough and filling to create multiple versions of Chocolate Peppermint Sandwich Cookies.

Different Chocolate Intensities

  • Use dark cocoa or even black cocoa for an Oreo-style color and flavor
  • Add extra chocolate chips or chunks for a double-chocolate effect

Peppermint Intensity & Mix-Ins

  • For subtle peppermint:
    • Use less extract and skip candy cane pieces in the dough
  • For bold peppermint:
    • Use a bit more extract
    • Add crushed candy canes into the cookie dough itself

Other Festive Flavor Ideas

  • Mocha peppermint cookies
    • Add instant espresso powder to the cookie dough for a coffee-and-mint combination
  • White chocolate peppermint
    • Use white chocolate chips in the cookie dough
    • Drizzle with white chocolate and top with peppermint
  • Orange chocolate peppermint
    • Add a hint of orange zest to the filling for a citrus twist

Serving & Gifting Ideas

Chocolate Peppermint Sandwich Cookies are a showstopper on a platter and a joy to give as gifts.

Serving Suggestions

  • Arrange them in concentric circles on a big white or red platter
  • Mix them with other cookies:
    • Gingerbread cookies
    • Sugar cookies
    • Shortbread

Pair with:

  • Hot chocolate or peppermint mochas
  • Coffee or espresso
  • Mulled drinks for a cozy winter vibe

Gifting Tips

These cookies are ideal for gifting because they look impressive and travel well.

Try:

  • Stacking a few in clear cellophane bags tied with ribbon
  • Laying them in metal cookie tins or sturdy boxes, layered between parchment
  • Adding a handwritten tag with the cookie name and a short note

You can even create themed gift sets with:

  • A small jar of hot cocoa mix
  • A festive mug
  • A packet of marshmallows

Storage, Freezing & Make-Ahead Tips

Short-Term Storage

  • Store Chocolate Peppermint Sandwich Cookies in an airtight container
  • Keep them in a cool spot
  • Separate layers with parchment to protect decorations and fillings

They often taste even better the next day, as the peppermint and chocolate have more time to mingle.

Freezing Options

You can freeze:

  • Cookie dough
    • Pre-scooped balls
    • Wrapped logs, ready to slice
  • Baked cookies (unfilled)
    • Cool completely, then freeze in airtight containers
  • Fully assembled sandwich cookies
    • Wrap individually or place in layers with parchment
    • Thaw gently so condensation doesn’t ruin the decorations

Thawing & Refreshing

To thaw:

  • Let cookies sit at room temperature in their container
  • Avoid unwrapping them immediately to prevent moisture from condensing directly on the cookies

If needed, you can briefly warm plain chocolate cookies (without filling) in a low oven to refresh the texture before filling.

Troubleshooting Common Problems

Even experienced bakers sometimes run into issues. Here’s how to fix the most common ones.

Cookies Spreading Too Much

If your cookies bake flat and thin:

  • Chill the dough longer
  • Make sure your butter isn’t too soft or melted
  • Check that you measured flour correctly
  • Bake on parchment or silicone mats rather than greased sheets

Dry or Cakey Cookies

If the texture feels too dry:

  • Make sure you’re not overbaking
  • Re-check your flour measurement
  • Use a scale for accuracy where possible

Filling Problems

  • Filling too runny:
    • Add more powdered sugar
    • Chill before piping
  • Filling too stiff:
    • Add a teaspoon of milk or cream at a time
    • Mix until creamy and pipeable

Peppermint Flavor Issues

  • Too strong:
    • Make a second batch of plain vanilla filling and mix it
    • Add more butter and powdered sugar to dilute the intensity
  • Too weak:
    • Add a little more peppermint extract, drop by drop
    • Taste as you go

FAQs: Chocolate Peppermint Sandwich Cookies

1. Can I make Chocolate Peppermint Sandwich Cookies ahead of time?
Yes. You can make the dough and chill it a day or two ahead, or freeze it for longer. The cookies themselves can be baked and stored in an airtight container for several days. You can also assemble the sandwich cookies a day or two in advance of serving.

2. How do I keep the filling from squishing out?
Use a filling that’s thick enough to hold its shape, don’t overfill the cookies, and let them sit for a bit after assembly so the filling can set up. A short chill in the fridge can also help.

3. Can I use candy canes instead of peppermint extract?
Crushed candy canes add peppermint flavor, but they mainly contribute crunch and color. For a strong, even peppermint flavor throughout the filling, you still need peppermint extract. Candy canes are perfect for decorating edges and tops.

4. What type of cocoa powder is best?
Both natural and Dutch-process cocoa can work, depending on the recipe. Dutch-process cocoa gives a deeper color and smoother flavor, while natural cocoa is brighter and more classic. Follow the specific recipe.

Conclusion

Chocolate Peppermint Sandwich Cookies are the ultimate holiday treat: a perfect balance of rich chocolate and cool peppermint wrapped up in a cookie that’s elegant enough for gifting yet simple enough for a cozy baking day at home.

Leave a Comment